Skip to main content

Table 2 Patient demographics comparing partial nephrectomy and radical nephrectomy over the 4 year study period

From: Evaluation of national trends in the utilization of partial nephrectomy in relation to the publication of the American Urologic Association guidelines for the management of clinical T1 renal masses

Demographics

Partial Nephrectomy

Radical Nephrectomy

p-value

 

N = 61693

N = 130078

 

Mean Age ± SE

58.3 ± 0.2

60.3 ± 0.2

<0.0001

Age Group

  

<0.0001

  <60

31251(50.7)

59090(45.4)

 

  ≥60

30441(49.3)

70988(54.6)

 

Gender

  

0.8440

  Male

35572(57.9)

74922(57.7)

 

  Female

25917(42.1)

54832(42.3

 

Race

  

0.6064

  Caucasian

40245(65.2)

83623(64.3)

 

  African-American

5249(8.5)

11570(8.9)

 

  Hispanic

4029(6.5)

9705(7.5)

 

  Asian

1007(1.6)

2425(1.9)

 

  Other

11162(18.1)

22755(17.5)

 

Income (Zip Code)

  

<0.0001

  <$50,000

27052(44.9)

64633(50.6)

 

  ≥$50,000

33242(55.1)

62976(49.4)

 

Hypertension

35436(57.4)

80297(61.7)

<0.0001

Diabetes

13701(22.2)

29806(22.9)

0.1767

Obesity

8673(14.1)

15687(12.1)

<0.0001

Chronic Kidney Disease

4683(7.6)

21060(16.2)

<0.0001

CKD Stages

  

<0.0001

  Stage 1

40(0.9)

60(0.3)

0.6139

  Stage 2

206(4.4)

586(2.8)

0.0421

  Stage 3

1246(26.6)

3144(14.9)

0.0004

  Stage 4

350(7.5)

1075(5.1)

0.0009

  Stage 5 / ESRD

40(0.8)

306(1.5)

<0.0001

  Stage unspecified

2800(59.8)

15890(75.4)

<0.0001

Charlson Comorbidity Index

  

<0.0001

  0

37308(60.5)

67959(52.2)

 

  1

15728(25.5)

29566(22.7)

 

  2

4323(7.0)

10636(8.2)

 

  3+

4334(7.0)

21916(16.8)

 

Insurance

  

<0.0001

  Private

34022(55.3)

57101(44.0)

 

  Medicare

20435(33.2)

55609(42.8)

 

  Medicaid

3575(5.8)

8684(6.7)

 

  Other

3531(5.7)

8387(6.5)

 

Hospital Bed Number

  

0.1792

  Small

5428(9.0)

11678(9.2)

 

  Medium

11508(19.1)

28038(22.0)

 

  Large

43265(71.9)

87867(68.8)

 

Hospital Nx Volume/year

  

<0.0001

  <25

1560(70.4)

6663(81.5)

 

  25-49

361(16.3)

942(11.5)

 

  50-99

184(8.3)

424(5.2)

 

  100+

112(5.1)

150(1.8)

 

Hospital Location

  

<0.0001

  Rural

2333(3.9)

8371(6.6)

 

  Urban

57868(96.1)

119212(93.4)

 

Hospital Region

  

0.0009

  Northeast

14324(23.7)

22913(17.9)

 

  Midwest

16723(27.6)

33770(26.3)

 

  South

17683(29.2)

43656(34.1)

 

  West

11795(19.5)

27828(21.7)

 

Teaching

  

<0.0001

  Non-teaching

15401(25.6)

47154(37.0)

 

  Teaching

44800(74.4)

82429(63.0)

 

Median Length of Stay (IQR), days

2.9(1.9-4.2)

3.4(2.2-5.2)

<0.0001

Median Total Charges for Stay (IQR), $

36832(26298–53058)

37359(25669–59124)

<0.001

Died during hospitalization

93(0.2)

1384(1.1)

<0.0001