Study+years | Period | Type | Location | Surgery | StoneSize | Gender | Age | BMI | LE | Quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Wu1 2017 [32] | 2016–2016 | RCT | Kidney | RIRS | < 17 | 66/21:66/24 | 47.1 + 1.0:46.9 + 1.2 | 24.5 + 0.3:24.1 + 0.3 | 1b | 5 |
Wu2 2017 [33] | 2015–2016 | RCT | upper urinary | ESWL | < 15 | 56/20:52/25 | 42.9 + 1.5:42.7 + 1.3 | 23.6 + 0.3:23.8 + 0.3 | 1b | 5 |
Tao 2018 [34] | 2017–2017 | RCT | upper ureter | ESWL | 1–20 | 83/44:96/48 | 49.6 + 6.1:50.4 + 5.7 | 23.6 + 2.9:23.1 + 3.3 | 1b | 5 |
Long 2016 [35] | 2014–2014 | RCT | LCS | ESWL | 6–20 | 20/14:22/15 | 44 + 9.5:45.8 + 9.9 | 25.2 + 3.4:25.6 + 2.9 | 1b | 3 |
Jing 2018 [36] | 2015–2016 | RCT | Ureter, kidney | ESWL | NA | 43/17:49/11 | 38.7 + 10.7:38.2 + 10.6 | 24.1 + 2.9:24 + 2.6 | 1b | 4 |
Albanis 2009 [37] | 28 months | Pro | LCS | ESWL | 20 | 37/13:39/11 | 39(19–70):36 (16–69) | NA | 2b | 8# |
Chiong 2005 [38] | Since 2001 | RCT | LCS | ESWL | 4–20 | 50/9:30/19 | 49 (21–71);45 (23–72) | 25.8 + 2.7:25.2 + 4.27 | 1b | 4 |
Pace 2001 [29] | 1999–2000 | RCT | LCS | ESWL | < 4 | 23/12:29/5 | 52 + 11.6:40.6 + 22.4 | NA | 1b | 3 |